Do Schools Face a Safety Problem or a Perception Problem?
Rosemont High School and Albert Einstein Middle School have bad reputations among some parents.
Note: This is the third and final part in a series about enrollment at Rosemont High School and Albert Einstein Middle School. Click here to read part one and click here to read part two.
One of the first things the new principal at Albert Einstein Middle School did this fall was spend less money on campus safety.
To Garrett Kirkland, it was plainly obvious that the school’s campus monitors were working way more than they needed to be.
“I started walking around the first day and–tell me where these hooligans are,” Kirkland said, adding that they now work fewer hours.
Just like many parents in the Rosemont area, he’d heard before he arrived at the campus that its students were rough and violent, and that safety was a big problem there. He said that doesn’t mesh with what he saw.
“The kids here are cared for,” Kirkland said.
Many Rosemont students attend middle school or high school somewhere else because Rosemont High School and Albert Einstein Middle School are perceived to be unsafe. The Sacramento City Unified School District’s open enrollment period ends this week, and those two schools are trying to turn around an ongoing decline in enrollment.
Administrators deny Rosemont High and Einstein are any less safe than others in the district, and say people who feel they’re especially violent are focusing on second-hand information.
Taya Tarango Mello, a Rosemont resident and parent of a George Washington Carver student, said several of her daughter’s former teachers advised her against Rosemont High School.
Mello said in an email that she “talked to several teachers and they told me that if I sent Kelsey to RHS it would be the worst thing I could do not only due to the lack of security (and) safety but the other aspects (like) teachers (and) administrative (issues).”
Rosemont High School Principal Leise Martinez said she encourages parents who have doubts about the school’s safety to come tour the Kiefer Boulevard campus.
“The best way to combat that (belief that the school is unsafe) is not believe what people say but just come and see for yourself,” Martinez said, adding that the school has a polite and respectful “community college atmosphere.”
Suspension data show Rosemont and Einstein near the middle of the pack
According to suspension data from the district, Rosemont and Einstein are far from the most violent schools–but they aren’t the most tranquil, either.
During the 2010-11 school year, Einstein had the second most suspensions at any Sacramento City Unified School District middle school with 172, while Rosemont had the third-fewest among comprehensive high schools with 222. But compare those numbers with the enrollment of each school and Einstein becomes No. 6 out of the district’s nine middle schools in terms of the fewest suspensions, while Rosemont had the third fewest out of six comprehensive high schools (scroll down to see the full data).
Among the district’s comprehensive high schools, only John F. Kennedy and West Campus had fewer suspensions-per-student than Rosemont.
But not everything shows up in the statistics.
Kirkland said at Einstein, one of the biggest challenges is getting students to report bullying. He said the school has taken steps to reduce bullying, but it’s still going to be present–just like it would be on any other campus.
“Whatever you're going to say about a school you can say about any school,” he said. “The best thing we can do is convince the kids it's a safe place to talk to us about the situation.”
Christina Pritchett, an occasional contributor to this site and the PTA president for both Einstein and Rosemont, said her daughter had troubles with bullying at the middle school level–but it was easy to resolve.
“Going into the elementary school and trying to get them to deal with the bullying problem was a lot more difficult than going into Albert Einstein and having them deal with it,” she said.
Pritchett said she’d heard the same rumblings from other parents about safety at Einstein and Rosemont before sending her kids there, but she said she hasn’t seen anything to make her question her decision.
“I feel 100 percent that my children are safe at either school–just from experience,” she said.
'That’s just not that many fights.'
Rosemont High School Assistant Principal Nathan McGill said he’s been at that school for seven years, and it’s more peaceful than he’s ever seen it.
“I don’t think the school has ever been as safe as it is now,” McGill said. “There have been maybe four or five fights this year–that’s just not that many fights.”
He said the school has stepped up its efforts to intervene before a problem escalates to violence. McGill said he, a counselor and the school’s other assistant principal often meet with students to mediate.
He agreed with the other officials, saying second-hand information about the school has spread throughout the area. He recalled a recent parent visit, where a mother spent some time in the halls during passing periods.
“She said she was surprised because what she saw was nowhere near what she had been hearing,” McGill said.
--
Note: This is the third and final part in a series about enrollment at Rosemont High School and Albert Einstein Middle School. Click here to read part one and click here to read part two.
--
2010-11 suspension data
| Middle Schools | 2010 - 2011 suspensions | 2010-11 enrollment | Suspensions per 100 students | Rank - fewest suspensions per 100 students |
| Albert Einstein | 172 | 805 | 21.4 | 6 |
| California | 108 | 688 | 15.7 | 3 |
| Fern Bacon | 126 | 611 | 20.6 | 4 |
| John Still Middle | 88 | 773 | 11.4 | 2 |
| Kit Carson | 119 | 346 | 34.4 | 9 - most suspensions per 100 students |
| Rosa Parks | 146 | 471 | 31 | 8 |
| Sam Brannan | 148 | 706 | 21 | 5 |
| Sutter | 38 | 1268 | 3 | 1 - fewest suspensions per 100 students |
| Will C. Wood | 199 | 723 | 27.5 | 7 |
| Comprehensive High Schools | ||||
| C.K. McClatchy | 316 | 2223 | 14.2 | 4 |
| Hiram Johnson | 288 | 1899 | 15.2 | 5 |
| John F. Kennedy | 203 | 2076 | 9.8 | 2 |
| Luther Burbank | 459 | 1966 | 23.3 | 6 - most suspensions per 100 students |
| Rosemont | 222 | 1583 | 14 | 3 |
| West Campus | 8 | 854 | 1 | 1 - fewest suspensions per 100 students |
Christina Pritchett
1:17 pm on Tuesday, February 7, 2012
Cody - Thank you for doing the homework and giving us the ratings. Just as I suspected, Rosemont Schools do not look so bad!
Brad
3:08 pm on Tuesday, February 7, 2012
Interesting data. Sadly both schools do appear to have a negative reputation, and I suspect that this obviously impacts enrollment. I'm curious about the suspensions you mention. I'm assuming that these are ALL suspension being reported, and not just those that would be categorized as a result of violent activity. Am I correct?
Jenniffer Herman
3:25 pm on Tuesday, February 7, 2012
It will be interesting to see what these stats will look like next year when SacCity cuts music, sports and counselors completely out of the district. What will be their outlet, I wonder?
Andrew Maalouf
4:18 pm on Tuesday, February 7, 2012
Dont judge on something you have no clue about. Thats how I feel about it. I LOVE ROSEMONT! It's a great atmosphere!
Michael House
1:36 pm on Wednesday, February 8, 2012
Prior to arriving at Rosemont High as a first year coach, I had also heard stories about how bad the campus was. It took only about two weeks for me to realize that a large part of what I had heard simply was not the case. Since my time at Rosemont, I have found a very large portion of the kids to be fun-loving, trouble free, and very respectful. While I have been involved with three other high school campuses, one that both my son and daughter attended, one they both played sports at, and one I worked at as a campus security, I can tell you that The Administrators at Rosemont are some of the best. Anyone spending just a fraction of time on the campus will clearly see the genuine concern for the welfare all of their students, something that in my opinion is questionable on other campuses. Guess it's like the old saying "Don't judge a book by its cover". So, I would say to parents of the Rosemont area, don't believe the hype. It's a great school with a greater atmosphere, and I am proud to be a Wolverine......thanks to all for the opportunity.....
Micaela Savage
4:17 pm on Wednesday, February 8, 2012
I am excited for my son to go to RHS! I am so glad he wont have to go to Johnson. He is @ Einstein right now, & we had an issue last year that was taken care of so quickly, it was unbelievable! He hasn't had any problems there so far. It also seems to be there are less fights this year than last. I have heard great things about Rosemont High from students that attend the school, as well as the parents. Unfortunately, some parents just bus their kids out of our community to attend different schools. That's too bad. It's not like we're living in Detroit, or Oakland or something.